Amazon Kindle or Barnes & Noble Nook

by BrendaReeves

For those planning to buy an ereader, the question arises: Should I buy the Amazon Kindle or the Barnes & Noble Nook? This calls for some research.

I've been a loyal Barnes & Noble customer for years. I used to live close to a store, and I would spend hours reading books while having a cup of coffee and dessert in the cafe. I also bought a lot of books. When they started selling Starbucks Coffee, I thought, now B & N is heaven. This is where I want to go when I die.

I've also been a loyal Amazon customer for many years. I knew I would eventually buy an ereader even though I didn't like the concept of reading a book on an electronic device, but you can't stop progress, so I had to get one.

How I made My Decision to Buy an EReader

One day in January, I happened to be in B&N with my elderly mother. We couldn't miss the Nook salesman straight ahead as we walked through the entrance. My mother has macular degeneration, an age related eye disorder that robs you of your sight. Mom has been an avid reader all of her life, and she was having difficulty reading print. I knew an ereader would prolong her ability to read as her eyesight deteriorated, so I stopped to talk to the salesman about the product.

I made my decision to purchase the Nook based on four reasons:

  1. I'm a push-over for sales people
  2. I like immediate gratification. I didn't want to wait for the Kindle to come in the mail.
  3. I'm loyal to B&N
  4. I'm impulsive

As you can see, my decision wasn't based on the quality of the product.

 

Barnes & Noble Nook

My mother read one book on the Nook. I read a couple of books, but most of the time I watch Netflix movies on it when I go to bed. I usually fall asleep half way through the movie, but I pick it up the next night. We both prefer to read a real book. There's something about holding a new book in your hands, smelling the pages and flipping through the to see what the titles of later chapters are. There are both positives and negatives with the Nook:

Pros:

  1. I don't have to run out to the book store to get a book anymore. Since I now live 25 miles from B&N, that's a big plus.
  2. If I decide I want a book to read at 11:30 at night, I can get it in seconds.
  3. I can watch movies.
  4. I can surf the web.

My cons:

  1. B&N is more expensive than Amazon.
  2. To get a discount, you have to pay $25 for their discount card.

Amazon Kindle

Since I don't own an Amazon Kindle, I can't really critique it, but the Kindle Fire looks like it does everything the Nook does. I bought the Nook that is the equivalent to the fire. However, I wish I had bought the Amazon Kindle. Here's why:

  1. Amazon's ebooks are cheaper than B&N's
  2. I now subscribe to Amazon Prime and get Amazon's movies. Along with that, I get free shipping on all of Amazon's products.
  3. I keep my music on Amazon's Cloud and I can listen to music on the Kindle

You're probably thinking, "Well, she hasn't told me anything I want to know." That's why I've included this You Tube video that compares the Kindle Fire and the Nook. It's an excellent review and should clear everything up for you, so you can make an informed decision.

Kindle Fire vs Nook Tablet: Comparison

BrendaReeves, on 07/24/2012
 
Thank you! Would you like to post a comment now?
3

Comments


   Login
katiem2 on 07/26/2012

C00l good to know I didn't watch the video since I have a Kindle I'm really attached to.

BrendaReeves on 07/25/2012

I am with you on that 100% Winterfate.Thanks for the comment. I always wondered that too, Katie. I didn't know until I watched that video. On the backside of the Nook where that is, there's a little flap where you can add more ram to it. Thakt's a big plus on the Nook for me.

Winterfate, the prices on the ebooks are creeping up to equal the same as the hard copy books. I knew they would eventually do that once they got us hooked.

katiem2 on 07/25/2012

Brenda, I got our Kindle Fires during Black Friday, they were $199.00 a piece and yet so worth it. The fire is amazing I do tell I say all the time they are like a mini iPad yet the size is much better.

I have a question, what's that notch in the corner cut out for on the nook? I've always wondered. :)K

Winterfate on 07/25/2012

I currently don't own an e-reader, and I believe it has something to do with what you said near the start of your article ("I didn't like the concept of reading a book on an electronic device").
While I'm quite techonologically inclined, one thing I'll never be able to replace, personally, is the nice smell of a new book and how it feels in my hands. How I can lay down in bed and read my favorite books. E-readers can't get me that.

With that said, digital books are cheaper than the hard copy counterpart, so that's something for the thrifty buyer.

But, if I'm going to get an e-reader, I'd probably get an Amazon Kindle, if only because Amazon is currently more popular than Barnes and Nobles. :)
Thanks for the great article! Liked and tweeted!

BrendaReeves on 07/24/2012

Thank you Sheilamarie and Katie. I love my Nook too, even though I mostly watch movies on it. I'm going to wait until the new model of the Kindle comes out at the end of the year and buy one.

katiem2 on 07/24/2012

I have a Kindle Fire, My daughter has a Kindle Fire and we love Love LOVE them. We too have always been big fans of Barnes and Noble but lately we go less and less shopping half priced books. We enjoy the thought of recycling books. We do head to Barnes and Noble to get the honors reading list for school as they always have them stocked.

sheilamarie on 07/24/2012

I haven't yet taken the plunge, so it's good to compare the two.



Disclosure: This page generates income for authors based on affiliate relationships with our partners, including Amazon, Google and others.
Loading ...
Error!