Easy and Tasty Tomato Cheese Pie Recipe

by bizilady

My mom makes a tomato cheese pie that is a satisfying and tasty dish. Many people confuse this with pizza,but it's not the same.

Tomato Cheese Pie Origins

Immigrants have influenced the eating habits of the American diet today. The "melting pot" of new customs and food items that came to this country gave us our great selection of recipes for every taste and budget. The cheese and tomato pie is one of my favorites.

The origins of the tomato cheese pie seem to originate in the early 1900's when poor Italian immigrants settled in the Philadelphia and Trenton areas. The recipe is not the familiar pizza that we are accustomed to eating today, as it is made from less expensive and readily available ingredients. If you had some tomatoes, and a hunk of cheese, and made a crust, then a tomato cheese pie was a quick and filling meal. When money was tight and there were many mouths to feed, this was the ideal solution.

This is not pizza

poor mans meal
Today this "poor mans" meal can be prepared with many variations, depending on what part of the US you live in. In the Northeast where I grew up, pizza shops are everywhere. True pizza parlors, as we referred to them, required a hot brick oven,that needed to be fired up hours ahead of time. The dry heat made the pie bake quickly and evenly. It also gave it a unique taste.
People will confuse this with a pizza, but it's not. The crust is different and the pie has tomato slices, unlike a pizza that usually has tomato paste and or sauce.
The home version is the tomato cheese pie that my mom still makes today. Her recipe is very tasty and probably the best I've had, if I do say so myself. I know many people make this but I prefer hers.

Tomato Cheese Pie photo

tomato Cheese Pie
tomato Cheese Pie
Stacie Bizilady

Ingredients for making tomato cheese pie

It is important to know that you can't use ricotta cheese - you must have the crumbly ricotta salada cheese or equivalent!
Frozen pie crust thawed 9" and a disposable aluminum pie pan
1 very large ripe tomato cut into 1/4" slices (salt and lay out on paper towels to absorb moisture)
1 medium onion
2 tablespoon butter
2 cloves of garlic
1 teaspoon of dried basil or some fresh basil leaves
tablespoon olive oil
a pinch of salt and pepper
2 oz. ricotta salada crumbled -1/2 cup (Italian market has this)
a cup or two of shredded mozzarella or fresh mozzarella or shredded cheese that you like

tomatoes green red still life ingredient
tomatoes green red still life ingredient

Directions for cooking the tomato cheese pie

1.Preheat oven to 400 degrees. Put the pie crust on a cooking sheet- prick bottom with fork and bake 8 minutes. COOL (I never use 400 degrees cause I think that’s too hot - try the recipe on the pie crust)
2. Reduce oven temp to 375 degrees while pie crust cools
3. Chop the onion and cook in the melted butter for about 2 minutes
4. Add the garlic and cook another minute. Let it cool down
5. Spread the ricotta salada onto bottom of pie crust with some chopped basil
6. Spread the onion/garlic mixture on top of cheese
7. Place alternate slices of the tomato on top of onions
8. Place mozzarella cheese on top of that
9. Brush the top with olive oil
10. Bake 20-25 minutes. cool and eat. The pie was excellent but don't puff pastry crust!!

mozarella italian cheese milk product food
mozarella italian cheese milk product...

No better, quick and easy pie than this to enjoy

Tomatoes and cheese never tasted so good!

So there is the recipe for mom's tomato cheese pie.  Just have a few items such as ripe tomatoes, onions,almost any cheese, a ready made or easy crust and you're good to go!

There are many variations to this dish, such as adding bacon, different cheeses, chopped tomatoes,chopped meat, pork, chicken and so on. The best thing about this dish is that it is versatile. You can make it different each time.

I love to see the cheese brown as it bakes in the oven. The aroma of the basil and onions makes my mouth water. Anyone that wants a quick and easy dish that is satisfying and filling, then this is the one to try!

Updated: 03/05/2017, bizilady
Thank you! Would you like to post a comment now?


Only logged-in users are allowed to comment. Login
bizilady on 07/19/2012

I hope you can share how your tomato pie turned out. I know you will love it!

bizilady on 07/19/2012

Tolovaj: Thank you for reading and commenting. i'd love to hear how your tomato pie turned out!

Sannel on 06/29/2012

This sounds so delicious and easy to make! I will bookmark and try it out myself soon. Thanks for sharing your mum's recipe with us.

Tolovaj on 06/17/2012

These certainly looks yummy. I think main difference between pizza and a pie is: at pizza we put ingredients on dough and at pie we put them on the crust which is already made (prepared). Slices of tomatoes don't qualify for the difference, although they are not so common anymore in some parts of the world. Living in neighboring country to pizza's home and knowing many Italians I already had a chance to try so called pizza primavera: with slices of tomato (and by the way, tomato came from America, what means it is not an 'original' ingredient, because pizza is much much older...).
Thanks for the recipe, it looks worth a trying.

bizilady on 04/07/2012

Mladen: I think you will like it.A tomato cheese pie is a simple dish to make.
Thanks for reading!

Mladen on 04/02/2012

I love it! I enjoy trying new recipes, and this tomato cheese pie looks DELICIOUS! Thank you for sharing this with us, bizilady!

bizilady on 02/15/2012

katiem2: thanks for commenting .I hope your daughters enjoy this version of a non pizza pie! LOL

katiem2 on 02/15/2012

Sounds great thanks for sharing one of your Moms treasures. My two daughters love tomatoe and cheese pizza so cheese pie will make for a great change. I love any kind of pie and now I can eat it for dinner.

BrendaReeves on 12/29/2011

I'm going to try this. My mother is a finicky eater, but I think she'll love it. Thanks!

bizilady on 12/09/2011

catgypsy: This is so simple to make and you can add other ingredients for your taste of the tomato and cheese pie. Thanks for reading and commenting.

You might also like

Pineapple Stir-Fry Chicken Served With Pork-Fried Rice Recipe

Two easy to follow healthy recipes that are both stir-fried. Fresh pineapple ...

Cooking Your Own Tongue: A Tongue In Cheek Recipe For Cooking ...

Cooking your own tongue is the natural way to obtain the best results. Cookin...

Disclosure: This page generates income for authors based on affiliate relationships with our partners, including Amazon, Google and others.
Loading ...