Movie Review of “Critic’s Choice”

by StevenHelmer

A review of the 1963 movie starring Lucille Ball and Bob Hope.

Synopsis: A successful theater critic faces his greatest writing challenge, reviewing a play his wife has written despite the fact he knows there’s a good chance he won’t like it and it will permanently damage their marriage if he writes the truth.
The movie stars Bob Hope, Lucille Ball, Jim Backus and Rip Torn.


Lucille Ball (photo courtesy of Pixabay)Since my wife recently started a new job and had her first night shift this past weekend, we decided not to go to church on Sunday morning so everyone could sleep in. However, thanks mostly to a cat that hadn’t gotten the memo, I was up relatively early and, since I had plenty of free time until my youngest daughter (the one morning person in our family) was out of bed, I ended up watching this movie.

When I started watching this film, I had some high expectations for it. I liked most of the Bob Hope movies I’ve seen and think Lucille Ball was a fantastic actress. Unfortunately, as it turns out, I just wasn’t overly impressed with this film.

The premise of the movie was halfway decent because it presented a no-win situation for Hope’s character. His reputation as a critic was on the line so it wasn’t as simple as refusing to review his wife’s (Ball) play. However, based on his one read-through of her script, he also knew there was a very good chance he wasn’t going to like it and would hurt her feelings.

Not helping him in all of this was an amorous director (Torn) that definitely had his eyes on Ball’s character. This, of course, meant if he did something to hurt her feelings, there was a really good chance the director would try to swoop in and steal her away. And, all of this got escalated when Hope’s character got drunk, didn’t watch the play but wrote a negative review about it anyway.

My biggest complaint about this movie was, even though it was supposed to be a comedy (or, at least I think that is what it was supposed to be), Hope and Ball just seemed to be a little too serious throughout. I’m not sure if that was a lack of effort on their part, the script or something else but, because of that the movie just wasn’t as enjoyable. Instead of being funny, a lot of their scenes together just seemed awkward. And, with the star power this movie had, that just should not have been the case.

Critic's Choice

1963 comedy pairing Lucille Ball and Bob Hope. Broadway fans will enjoy the inside jokes of this movie based on a play by Ira Levin. Ball is a young playwright while Hope is her...

View on Amazon

Final Opinion

The movie has an interesting premise and I probably would be interested in seeing the play it was based off of. However, the flatness of the film’s two surprisingly unfunny stars just made this movie not as entertaining as I thought it would be.

My Grade: C

More By This Writer

A Messy House is a Home

In this companion book to "Love Poems for My Wife," Steven Helmer uses poetry to express his feelings about being a husband, a parent and about life in general.

View on Amazon

Updated: 03/23/2015, StevenHelmer
Thank you! Would you like to post a comment now?


Mira on 04/29/2015

I haven't seen any Lucille Ball movies, and I'd like to see one if you find anything good in the future. Thank you for your reviews!

You might also like

Movie Review of "Gilda"

A review of the 1946 black & white movie starring Rita Hayworth and Glenn Ford.

Movie Review: The Sea Hawk (1940)

A review of the 1940 pirate movie that pairs Errol Flynn and Claude Rains.

Movie Review of “The Island of Lost Souls”

A review of the 1932 movie starring Bela Lugosi and Charles Laughton.

Disclosure: This page generates income for authors based on affiliate relationships with our partners, including Amazon, Google and others.
Loading ...