Introduction
Roman Writers
The Chinese contribution
Discussion
Conclusion

There is a claim that a mysterious darkness fell on the Earth for three hours when Jesus was crucified
Introduction
Roman Writers
The Chinese contribution
Discussion
Conclusion
Extraordinary events are often recorded, but their explanations are controversial. Sceptics deny that there is anything special about the event. It was an eclipse, they affirm. Such a one was Thassus., a pagan Roman writer who decided that the darkness was an unexpected eclipse. Julius Afrianus, writing in the early fourth century, cited the works of Thassus, which are known today only in fragments. These promoted the eclipse theory, though they claimed that it was un unusually long eclipse. Phlegon wrote in a similar vein, but Origen, a renowned Christian writer took up the challenge. Eclipses, he stated happen only at full moon. The Passover, the festival during which Jesus was crucified, always takes at the first sabbbath after the first full moon of the month of Nisan.
It is an astronomical fact that solar . ..eclipses do not happen at full moon, but they happen at new moon. so as the crucifixion occurred round about full moon an eclipse could not happen. . There was a lunar eclipse about the time of the crucifixion, when the moon characteristically went red, but this would only be visible at night, so it does not account for day time darkening.
Other writers brought up the issue. the fact that people ere thinking of the best explanation of the phenomenon means that it cannot be wished away. Modern Liberal Christians tend to treat the phenomenon as fictitious, meant to justify Christian faith in Jesus; significance. But any documentary account from nonChristian cultures that affirms the darkness would fatally undermine the liberal belief. Sources from India, Iran or China that made reference to the darkness would undermine the sceptical belief.
The documentary support for the darkness comes from an unlikely source China. The Chinese were governed by the Han dynasty during the period in which the phenomenon occurred, 31 to 33 AD.. The Emperors of China took astrology seriously, and they were keen on predicting eclipses because they were thought to be messages from Shang di, the high God, who was above form and was above the heavens. So seriously did they take eclipses that astronomers who failed to predict an eclipse would suffer the death penalty.
But in the early thirties A.D. there was an unusual event, an unpredicted solar phenomenon occurred, causing the sunlight to be dimmed for the hours between modern 12 o clock and six pm, the hours when Jesus was on the cross. Six hours, this is far in excess of the seven to ten minute timing of an eclipse of the sun. The people from the emperor downwards were terrified. There is no record of astronomers being executed, as the emperor realized that this not an event in the ordinary run of things, but it behoved the emperor to make an act of devotion assuage the obvious anger of Shang Di. the high God. Furthermore, the penitent emperor issued a decree that all prisoners would be released. On the third day after the darkening the sun had a rainbow aura around it.
The fact that a mysterious solar phenomenon was seen in two separate spaces, several thousand miles apart, and probably in other places as well, discredits explanations derived from astronomical or atmospheric phenomena mrely local to the Middle East. Dust storms do not stretch from the Middle East to China. Clouds are world wide so the Chinese, who are an educated people knew how to distinguish clouds from other aerial features. We are dealing with a solar phenomenon of world wide extent. It was by no means an eclipse. The eclipse theory is the most credible from among poor, inadequate explanations.
The fact that a person who had displayed strange powers and was thought by some to be linked to God cannot be overlooked. A supernatural event or a miracle cannot be ruled out. There is no other credible solution.

Comments
frankbeswickJun 29, 2026
The kind of meat used in red onion casserole could be mutton, lamb or beef. A wide variety is available to choose including beans and peas.
Meat pies are made of mince.
frankbeswickJun 29, 2026
The kind of meat used in red onion casserole could be mutton, lamb or beef. A wide variety is available to choose including beans and peas.
Meat pies are made of mince.
frankbeswickJun 29, 2026
The kind of meat used in red onion casserole could be mutton, lamb or beef. A wide variety is available to choose including beans and peas.
Meat pies are made of mince.
frankbeswickJun 29, 2026
The kind of meat used in red onion casserole could be mutton, lamb or beef. A wide variety is available to choose including beans and peas.
Meat pies are made of mince.
frankbeswickJun 29, 2026
The kind of meat used in red onion casserole could be mutton, lamb or beef. A wide variety is available to choose including beans and peas.
Meat pies are made of mince.
frankbeswickJun 29, 2026
The kind of meat used in red onion casserole could be mutton, lamb or beef. A wide variety is available to choose including beans and peas.
Meat pies are made of mince.
frankbeswickJun 29, 2026
The kind of meat used in red onion casserole could be mutton, lamb or beef. A wide variety is available to choose including beans and peas.
Meat pies are made of mince.
DerdriuMarrinerJun 29, 2026
A west-pond casserole generally contains macaroni and cheese. A meat pie generally designates mince.
What else is in your red-onion casserole?
What kind of meat is in your red-onion pie?
frankbeswickJun 28, 2026
DerdriuMarrinerJun 27, 2026
How do you do a "good-meal" red onion: baked, cooked, fresh, fried, grilled, souped?
frankbeswickJun 27, 2026
DerdriuMarrinerJun 26, 2026
What gives red onions the Beswick-growing -- ;-D -- edge over other onions?
frankbeswickJun 25, 2026
DerdriuMarrinerJun 24, 2026
All life always gives us learning experiences, doesn't it?
frankbeswickJun 24, 2026
DerdriuMarrinerJun 23, 2026
Do we understand everything -- such as this "really strange miracle" -- with death?
frankbeswickJun 22, 2026
DerdriuMarrinerJun 22, 2026
Could it be that a religious/spiritual tradition and a scientific explanation considers correctly such darkness even as we not yet comprehend such respectively symbolic and scientific configurations?
frankbeswickJun 22, 2026
frankbeswickJun 20, 2026
DerdriuMarrinerJun 20, 2026
The film The Coming Convergence came out just afore the pandemic shutdown. It considered the worldly ending.
The afore-designated film drew on biblical references.
Is there any tradition as to what a world ending involves, such as possibly darkness over all the earth?
DerdriuMarrinerFeb 27, 2026
Among my favorites words from Jesus Christ are "Into Thy hands I commend my spirit" and "I will be with you always, even until the end of the world."
What is the Beswick interpretation of "the end of the world"? Might it mean a final end or an end also a beginning?
frankbeswickFeb 25, 2026
DerdriuMarrinerFeb 23, 2026
Couldn't we consider the sky darkening and then clearing as communicating in supernaturally symbolic images, in supernaturally imaged symbolism Jesus Christ asking, My God why hast Thou forsaken me?, and He and God answering, Into Thy hands I commend my spirit?
It's the beautiful comfort of Godly rainbows after unsettling storms and weather!
frankbeswickFeb 21, 2026
DerdriuMarrinerFeb 21, 2026
It's inspiring to read this as I initiate what I always implement during the Lenten weeks: listening to the Bible in the languages that I know and, for a few years now, Be Thou My Vision dedicated to you and Maureen and your family and to Veronica and her husband and their family.
Why mightn't Someone for whom the world and its animal, phenomena, plant inhabitants mattered muster something such as a marvelous, miraculous supernatural event?
teddletonmrFeb 21, 2026