Dick Whittington and His Cat

by Tolovaj

Dick Whittington and His Cat is a less-known fairy tale about a poor boy who came to London and after initial disappointments made a fortune. How much truth is in it?

Outside of England, just die-hard fans of fairy tales heard about Dick Whittington and His Cat but everybody is familiar with Puss in Boots. The plot is essentially the same - make the best of your life even if the chances are not in your favor. If you play your hand right, you can win even if your cards are not the best.

In both stories, a very important role is reserved for the cat. But there is one very important difference: while the miller's son could be almost anybody, Richard (Dick) Whittington was a real person who lived in the 14th and 15th centuries. He was very rich, politically successful, and left a lasting impact on society.

Dick Whittington on his way to London by R. Anning Bell

1. Real Richard Whittington

Richard Whittington was born around 1354. As the third son in a wealthy family (his father was a Knight and member of Parliament), he couldn't count on inheritance, but his family was willing to pay a scholarship. This meant he had to leave home and try to earn his own fortune.

Just like Dick in the story who was poor, couldn't count on any serious opportunity in his village, and decided to go. Dick in the story is an orphan and real Richard lost his father when he was about four, what is another similarity.

Dick Whittington in London by George Cruikshank

2. Real London

Real Richard and fictional Dick both left their homes and went to London. Dick in the fairy tale believed he'll immediately become rich in London where even the streets are paved with gold. Well, he soon found out that life in London wasn't any better than in his home environment. But some people in London were rich and when fe found one with a good heart, an opportunity came.

Richard came to London to study. He knew that knowledge and connections could bring him money, maybe even more than he would inherit if he was a firstborn. But he also knew that he should work for his success. London wasn't a nice place but it offered opportunities that were not available elsewhere.

The majority of fairy tales are located in unspecified places. To place Dick Whittington in London is unusual.

Guildhall Chapel was rebuilt with Richard Whittington's money

3. Real Fitzwarren

Dick Whittington gets shelter and a job at Mr. Fitzwarren who is a merchant ad has a daughter Alice who likes the boy and later becomes his wife. This is another deviation from the standard practice in fairy tales. Characters rarely have names and almost never surnames. In cases where they are named, their names are common like Hans or Jack.

Real Dick Whittington married Alice Fitzwaryn. The name is the same as in the fairy tale and her surname is very similar.

4. Real Mercer

In the story, we have a merchant who takes the boy under his roof. He insists that Dick sends his only possession overseas and tries to trade it which makes Dick (who was just a kitchen boy at the time) a merchant as well. He gets extraordinary wealth for his cat.

Richard Whittington went to London to become a mercer. He not only succeded in his profession but became rich beyond expectation. He was so successful that many important people including two (!) kings became his debtors.

Ship with Fitwarren's goods, illustration by George Cruikshank

5. Real Ship

In the fairy tale, Dick sends the cat by the ship. It was a very usual way of trading.

Richard Whittington got permission to export woolen cloth from the king and imported luxury goods like velvet and silk. He built a large part of his fortune by trading but his lending was probably even more important because it gave him leverage on influential people.

Dick Whittington becomes rich, illustration by R. Anning Bell

6. Real International Trading

The fairy tale explicitly tells that trading is done in another kingdom where the king has a lot of gold but can't get rid of the rats.

Real Whittington also traded with foreign countries. He just didn't rely on one shipment.

7. Real Royalties

We have already mentioned that Dick's wealth came from the king who was thankful for the extermination of mice and rats.

We have also mentioned that the real Richard lent money to real kings. These were Henry IV and Henry V. They both helped him with many permissions he had to acquire to trade specific goods.

Dick Whittington's cat in action, illustration by Kate Greenaway

8. Real Financial Success

Poor boy in the fairy tale almost overnight became so rich he could 'buy nice clothes for himself and presents for everybody in the house of Fitzwarren'. The story ends with his marriage and the statement that he is very rich now.

Richard Whittington became rich and important (four times a mayor of London and member of Parliament, among other achievements). He established many charitable projects during his life and left to charity a huge amount of money (several millions of pounds in today's money. Today, six centuries after his death, some of those projects are still active.

Dick Whittington is being groomed, illustration by R. Anning Bell

9. Real Marriage

Dick in the fairy tale married Alice, the daughter of his landlord. We expect that they live happily ever after.

In reality, Richard married Alice when he was already way over forty and she was about two decades younger. Their marriage was childless and she died relatively young about a decade before him.

Dick Whittington marries Alice Fitzwarren, illustration by Kate Greenaway

10. Real Cat

The cat in the story serves as the tool. It kills rodents and is sold to the king overseas.

There is no evidence that the real Richard Whittington ever had a cat. But there is a drawing with Richard and a cat. This picture was made in the 19th century by a printer who didn't like the original painting (made many years after Richard's death by Reginald Elstrack) where the mayor sits with a hand leaning on the skull. The fairy tale with Richard and the cat was already popular in the 19th century and the printer just wanted to meet the expectations of his customers.

Comparison of Richard's Whittington's portraits
Updated: 03/13/2024, Tolovaj
 
Thank you! Would you like to post a comment now?
44

Did you know that Dick Whittington and His Cat is based on true people and events?

Only logged-in users are allowed to comment. Login
Tolovaj on 03/22/2024

I have heard about the series but didn't watch it. If it comes on my menu, I will look for Rollo.

Tolovaj on 03/22/2024

This is an interesting theory. Dates match but I don't know about the cats in London in those days.

Tolovaj on 03/22/2024

Dick is short for Richard. It sounds more friendly, less serious. It like Hansel instead of Johannes in German fairy tales.

Tolovaj on 03/22/2024

I believe it was imagination.

Tolovaj on 03/22/2024

I don't know. One or more of the people who were close to Richard Whittington was probably involved, but the story very likely evolved through many years and retellings.

Tolovaj on 03/22/2024

None specific. Whatever my research brings.

DerdriuMarriner on 03/20/2024

The Geni site has the Richard Whittington genealogy from his father backward paternally 10 generations:

William Whittington V (1310-1359)
William Whittington IV (1280-1332)
William Whittington III (1260-1280), relocated from Warwick to Newent, Gloucestershire, England
William Whittington II (1235-1283)
William de Whitynton (1210-?)
Guy de Witinton III (1180-?)
Guy de Vyteinsen II (1150-?), relocated from northern France to Warwick, Warwickshire, England
Guy de Vyteinsen (1120-?)
Richard de Vyteinsen (1090-?)
Guy de Vyteinsen (1060-?).

Jason Scott Wills, as manager of the Whittington information, identifies the first Guy de Vyteinsen (born 1060) as immigrating to England with William the Conqueror and as in The Doomsday Book. He identifies Vyteinsen as an ancient family name in northern France.

Vyteinsen looks Norse to me, as a Norse descendant and as an admirer of Icelandic author Ragnar Jónasson.

So Richard Whittington ultimately might have descended from Rollo (835?/870?-928?/933), Danish or Norwegian Viking-born ducal ancestor of William the Conqueror.

Might you have watched the 2022 television series Vikings? The character Rollo was part of the aforementioned plot.

DerdriuMarriner on 03/20/2024

The Black-Death plague maximized its casualties and its damages between 1346 and 1353.

Perhaps Richard Whittington -- born perhaps one year later, in 1354, and braving post-plague London perhaps concerned about plague relapses the next, vulnerable 75 to 100 years -- numbered among his pre- and post-humous projects plague survivors and those with plague-killed, plague-surviving family members.

Such sympathetic support to those so suffering possibly would suggest symbolic association with feline sentients who worked against plague flea-riddled mice and rats. Perhaps that subsequently suggested Dick Whittington and his cat, right?

DerdriuMarriner on 03/19/2024

It intrigues me that the real Richard Whittington is the nicknamed Dick Whittington in the fairy tale.

Is it known when Dick showed up as a nickname, whether or not anyone slipped it into conversation about or to Richard and why it supplanted Richard in the fairy tale?

DerdriuMarriner on 03/19/2024

The first, in-text image, above the first reality, Real Richard Whittington, contains what could be a coat-of-arms or a sign to an eatery or an inn.

Is this a case of "artistic license" in which the image illustrator lodges within his interpretation something not in the original story?

If not, what might the animal-sentient species be?


You might also like

The Puss in the Boots

Puss in Boots is one of eight fairy tales written by Charles Perrault's Mothe...

The Pied Piper of Hamelin - The Background of the Story

The legend of the Pied Piper of Hamelin is based on true events, but nobody k...


Disclosure: This page generates income for authors based on affiliate relationships with our partners, including Amazon, Google and others.
Loading ...
Error!