Graded Coins: Advantages and Disadvantages

by blackspanielgallery

The question of whether it is better to purchase graded coins over those not graded is not simple to answer. Much has to be considered.

First, there are many grading companies out there. In order for the graded coin to be accepted as being the grade it is claimed to be the person buying the coin must respect the grading company’s work. Most coin collectors will readily accept PCGS, NGC, ANACS, and IGC. PCGS is highly recognized, and NGC has a relationship with the American Numismatics Association.

ANACS was the first grading service in response to the need of collectors to authenticate coins as genuine, and is still highly respected as the authority on ancient coins. ICG is usually the grading services used for many Canadian coins.

Are Graded Coins Accurately Graded?

A graded coin is the result of a subjective view of a person working for one of the grading services.  Most are right on the mark if the grading service is careful in hiring the graders, but even the top services can err due to the subjectivity of the art of grading a coin.  In the current market where uncirculated coins are given a number from 60 through 70 the differences in the adjacent grades is minute, and errors can be easily made.


The Advantages

If a coin is graded a collector can purchase it with added confidence.  In higher grades one level, say from a MS-65 to a MS-66 grade, can mean quite a bit of difference in value.  So, a graded coin gives some confidence to the purchaser of a coin.


The other advantage is authenticity of the piece.  A reputable grading service will not place a counterfeit or altered piece into a slab.  Remember, such things as changing a mintmark can significantly change the value of a coin, so if it has been altered it becomes worthless to a collector. 


A grading service can also provide a value for a graded coin, other than new coins that are still being produced.  Unless the coin is so rare it needs to be bid to establish a value, or is too new, most graded coins have a value associated with them on the grading service’s website.



1992 S Silver Proof Roosevelt Dime PCGS PR 69 DCAM New Blue Label Holder

Obverse: The current design on the obverse of the dime first appeared in 1946, soon after the death of President Franklin Delano Roosevelt. The Roosevelt dime was released on th...

View on Amazon

2015 American Silver Eagle $1 MS69 - First Strike - First Day PCGS

2015 American Silver EagleCertified PCGS MS69 - First Strike - First DayAmerican Eagle Silver Bullion Coins are affordable investments, beautiful collectibles, thoughtful gifts ...

View on Amazon

2007 S Proof Sacagawea Dollar PCGS PR 69 DCAM New Blue Label Holder

The Sacagawea Dollar Obverse design retains the central figure of the Sacagawea design first produced in 2000 with the inscriptions LIBERTY and IN GOD WE TRUST. The Reverse side...

View on Amazon

2016 Royal Canadian Mint Canada BATMAN VS SUPERMAN First Strike SILVER Proof $20 SP69 PCGS

A 2016 Royal Canadian Mint Silver $20 DC Comics Batman VS Superman Coin, graded SP69 FIRST STRIKE by PCGS. It is in stunning near PERFECT condition. This coin has the special "F...

View on Amazon

1943 Lincoln Cent Choice Brilliant Uncirculated Steel Penny MS63 PCGS

Beautiful steel Lincoln Penny, professionally graded by PCGS. Coin grades MS63. Full strike, blemish free, excellent addition to any collection. On hand and ships immediately.

View on Amazon

2017 S U.S. Mint Enhanced Uncirculated Coin Set SP-70 PCGS (FS) SP70

For the first time ever the U.S. Mint has released a set of U.S. coins in a special Enhanced Uncirculated finish. These coins feature frosted devices on an unpolished field givi...

View on Amazon

Use the Grading Service’s Website

There is an unfortunate situation in that counterfeiters, especially in China, are not only counterfeiting coins but also the slabs.  The grading services are constantly changing their slabs with hidden marks and holograms to combat this threat.  But, one quick thing one can do is to look up the serial number online.  If the serial number indicates a nickel and the coin is a quarter, there is a problem.  The matching of serial numbers is not yet in common use by the counterfeiters.


Also, when the serial number is checked there will be a value.  It should be slightly higher than if the coin were not graded.  Grading coins is expensive, so having a graded coin should involve including the cost of the service.


The Disadvantages of Graded Coins

Many collectors do not like coins encased in plastic.  They want to view even the edges on the coins.  So, they break the slabs and remove the coins.  The coin still is the grade it once was, but no longer can the collector recoup the extra value associated with having a graded piece. 


Grades Change

Coins are subject to environmental damage.  If a coin had been improperly handled prior to being placed in the protective slab the coin could react to whatever was left on it, and later changes can occur.  Look at the coin, especially if it has been encased for a long time.  This can be determined because the slabs and labels have gone through changes over the years, so an estimate of about how long a coin has been encased is possible.


Identification of Your Property

The serial number on the slab is unique, and can be used to help identify your property in the event of theft.  Keep a record of the serial numbers separate from your collection.  

Slabs Are Easily Stored

Slabs are rectangular, and can be easily stored.  In fact there are boxes designed to hold graded coins.  However, the labels make the slabs larger than other protection one might apply to coins, such as capsules or flips.  The slabs take up space.  But they offer excellent physical protection of the coins in them.


Be careful when buying a box.  The different grading services use slightly different size slabs, so make certain your graded coins will fit well into the box.


NGC Slab Boxes

Aluminum Storage & Display Box Case Holds 100 PCGS NGC ANACS C...

Time left: 4 weeks
Current bid: $59.95  Place bid

SILVER BOX Brand New NGC Storage Plastic Box ~ Each Box Holds ...

Time left: 3 weeks, 4 days
Current bid: $13.54  Place bid


Time left: 4 weeks, 1 day
Current bid: $14.14  Place bid

PCGS Slab Boxes

Aluminum Storage & Display Box Case Holds 100 PCGS NGC ANACS C...

Time left: 4 weeks
Current bid: $59.95  Place bid

One (1) Used Empty PCGS CLEAN Plastic Storage Box Blue Holds 2...

Time left: 5 days, 19 hours
Current bid: $6.75  Place bid

SILVER BOX Brand New NGC Storage Plastic Box ~ Each Box Holds ...

Time left: 3 weeks, 4 days
Current bid: $13.54  Place bid

In Conclusion

The choice of whether or not to have a coin graded, or pay a little extra for a graded coin, rests with the collector.  The security that an expert in grading has proclaimed the coin a certain grade, albeit subjectively, and authenticity must be weighed against the extra cost and the inability to see the coin outside of the slab.  In addition, to not have a graded coin places the responsibility to protect the coin against physical and environmental damage on the owner of the coin.

The Limitations

Even a graded coin cannot give the province or history of the coin.  The only way to be certain your coin was not stolen, then later encased in a slab, is to purchase directly your coins directly from a mint.   


This article contains links to affiliate programs from some or all of Amazon, Zazzle, Viglink, and Ebay through Viglink, and Adsense advertising.  These must use cookies to allow for proper crediting.


The introduction image is of one of our images, and we own the rights to the image used in creating the product.

Updated: 09/18/2017, blackspanielgallery
Thank you! Would you like to post a comment now?


blackspanielgallery on 09/15/2017

It depends on the value of the coin. I like capsules, since they protect against physical and environmental damage, but they cost one to three dollars, depending on the size. 2X2 mylar flips also do the job much cheaper, but mylar can tear and damage occur. It is also not as hard as capsules. Vyna flips are good for temporary solutions such as protection during shipping at a reasonable cost. The thing to remember is it is not a good idea to spend more than the value of a coin to protect it, which can easily happen even with Indian head pennies.

DerdriuMarriner on 09/15/2017

blackspanielgallery, What is the best way to protect coins when foregoing grading?

You might also like

Art Contest with Collectible Coins

The State of Alaska has an interesting art contest annually. The winning des...

Unusual Coins and Currency of the United States

The United States has had many different and unusual coins and paper currency...

Disclosure: This page generates income for authors based on affiliate relationships with our partners, including Amazon, Google and others.
Loading ...