The Golden Age of Mystery: Why Is It Given This Lofty Title?

by FloraBreenRobison

The Golden Age of Mystery is a term used for the era between the World Wars. There are strong reasons why this term is warranted.

The Golden age of Mystery refers to the period of years between WWI and WWII. The plethora of mystery writers in Britain and North America who started their careers during this era include some of the most loved and most enduring writers of all time in this genre. The influence of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle's Sherlock Holmes is everywhere.

Why the Era Between the World Wars Was Golden

Whether or not you are a fan of mystery and suspense fiction, you have probably heard the term Golden Age of Mystery. You may even know that this era encompasses the years between World War I and World War II. Certainly you know this if are a fan of mystery and suspense. What is it about this period of years that warrants the term Golden Age when

a) the men and women who wrote detective stories  during this era had careers much longer than the two decades between the end of World War I in 1918 and the year that England-a hot bed of mysteries-joined World War II in 1939; and

b) Sherlock Holmes is generally considered by everyone to be the greatest detective of all time and he was created during the Victorian era?



First of all, titles are given to eras in history after the fact. No one knew at the time the era began that there would be a plethora of authors-many, but not all of them female-who would create their own series detective and launch a mystery writing career between the World Wars. Some detectives had their own Dr. Watson narrators. Some were amateurs. Some were police officers of various ranks, either at Scotland Yard or in an American city. Some lived in a large city like London or New York. Some lived in small towns that were totally fictitious. Some mysteries read like a Murder Most Cozy , some were Impossible Locked Room Mysteries, some focused on the criminal, some followed private eyes, some followed lawyers, and some were Police Procedurals. Yet if you ignore all the variations of Golden Age mysteries and look at the names of and amount of famous authors who first published either a short story or novel between 1918 and 1939 who are still read today by a wide audience of mystery fans, you realize that this has to be the Golden Age of Mystery.



Here are some examples of authors and their creations who debuted between 1918 and 1939:


 Margery Allingham and Albert Campion

John Dickson Carr and Gideon Fell

Raymond Chandler and Phillip Marlowe

G.K. Chesterton and Father Brown

Agatha Christie  and Hercule Poirot

Agatha Christie and Miss Jane Marple

Carter Dixon (Carr) and Sir Henry Merrivale

Franklin Dixon and The Hardy Boys

Erle Stanley Gardner and Perry Mason

Carolyn Keene and Nancy Drew

Ngaio Marsh and Roderick Alleyn

Dorothy L. Sayers and Lord Peter Whimsey

Rex Stout and Nero Wolfe

The Influence Of Sherlock Holmes

The Detective and His Narrator


Sherlock Holmes inspired several men and women to create their own detective and sidekick team, regardless of whether the sidekick narrated the book like Dr. Watson or whether there was no narrator at all. All of the detectives had unique characteristics that separated them from the characters of other writers, even if the paradigm were the same.This is true of both British and American authors. Take Christie and Stout.

Agatha Christie created Hercule Poirot and his narrator Captain Hastings. Poirot was a Belgian detective who was forced to flee his country where he had been a policeman to England during WWI. He was fastidiously tidy, loved order and method, and talked of his "little grey cells." Hastings had been wounded during the war and met Poirot in Europe before being reunited in The Mysterious Affair at Styles in 1920. She got tired of Hastings and married him off, although he turned up from time to time. From then on Poirot had no narrator--except for the famous The Murder of Roger Ackroyd.

Rex Stout on the opposite side of the Atlantic Ocean created Nero Wolfe and Archie Goodwin. Both were private eyes who had never been on the police force. Wolfe was an large man who was dangerously obese, rode an elevator in his own private home, and had a strict time schedule to his day. He hated to be interrupted when he was tending to his beloved orchids and woe to the man or woman who thinks he or she has business more important than orchids. Goodwin was a devil-may-care ladies man who did all of Wolfe's legwork for him. Wolfe could not have survived without his narrator. To say the least, Stout never married off Goodwin.

What of the fact that Holmes is Victorian and has continued to be given new mysteries through to today? It is true that Holmes is the best, came back from the dead, and transcends the generations perhaps even more popularly now than any time since Doyle died. But Doyle was very much alone in his success in standing the test of time. Even during the time Doyle was writing, other writers and their detectives did not have the same success. Some are entirely forgotten today. The one possible exception is R. Austin Freeman who created Dr. Thorndyke and his faithful biographer, Jervis. It is perhaps no coincidence that Thorndike is a medical man who was modeled after a real person and that he had a logical method to solving crimes forensically.

Time will tell whether the current writers of mystery will have been living in a second Golden Age of Mystery

Links for the Golden age of Mystery
Agatha Chrsitie's official website
The official Dorothy L. Sayers website for her society.
The John Dickson Carr Society's website

Do You Read Mysteries From the Golden Age Of Mystery?

  Display results
This Involves Preferences
Updated: 04/06/2012, FloraBreenRobison
Thank you! Would you like to post a comment now?


Only logged-in users are allowed to comment. Login
FloraBreenRobison on 05/03/2012

Yes, Poe is the father of the modern detective story. I've been a fan of Christie since I was a child and have always been intrigued by her real life. Thanks for your thoughts on these famous authors and the Golden age.

Thanks too for sharing the article. Flora

PDXJPrice on 05/03/2012

Nice work, Flora. Very interesting. I've always enjoyed the work of Agatha Christie, and I love that her real life (and death) are mysterious.

It's interesting that both Sir Arthur Conan Doyle and Edgar Allen Poe (who is considered the father of the modern detective story) were created well before these so called authors of the golden age.

Nice work. Liked and shared

FloraBreenRobison on 04/09/2012

Brenda-well then, you have lots of books waiting around to be discovered for the first time! I envy you that. I love to reread my favourites. But to find books that I've yet to read in this genre is rare among those that are easily found. There are quite a large number of books that can only be found in used bookstores-but to find them before they are bought by someone else...

BrendaReeves on 04/09/2012

Wonderful information. I feel like I've read through all the genres except mystery and suspense. I better get started. Great article.

FloraBreenRobison on 04/08/2012

Hi, Dave!
I do memorize quite a lot of details. How useful this information is depends upon what you do with it. :) I'm sure there a lot of people who know the lyrics to Gilligan's Island's theme song who are embarrassed to admit it. But to write about literature-in particular, mystery and suspense genres- and classic Hollywood is a passion of mine. Thus, the knowledge is beneficial.

I'll let you in on a secret, though-when I haven't slept well, I don't have a great memory of today's events either.

Take care,


davenmidtown on 04/08/2012

I am always amazed by the depth of your knowledge of literature, movies and cinema. My poor brain just does not work like that and I have a hard time remembering who I met this morning let alone who played the part of X. Awesome job!

FloraBreenRobison on 04/07/2012

Joseph- Hello! Glad you enjoyed this article. Thanks for sharing that you love Christie and Conan Doyle too. I must confess I have several copies of their titles, not just one of each.

Joseph De Cross on 04/07/2012

Thanks for refreshing our minds Flora with this lofty piece. Sir Arthur conan Doyle and Agatha Christie are our favorite writers indeed. Thanks!

FloraBreenRobison on 04/06/2012

Kelly-I'm still getting used to this new site. I read Nancy Drew hardcovers in order. I had a library card, but when it came to my favourite mystery authors I would collect them, rather than borrow them. I still have a lot of them. I am willing to part with books of other genres, but I reread mysteries. Some of the authors that aren't as famous as the big names cannot be found except in used book stores-or online. and I love to hold a real book in my hand.

Kelly on 04/06/2012

I was just messing around on Wizzley:) Trying to figure the program out!

I always was an avid reader...I was about 8 or 9 when I was allowed my first Library Card from the public library. I got a ride every week so I could trade my Nancy Drew books in:) lol. I think I read them all in one summer. I tried to introduce them to my daughters but they are just too old school for them. Sad! But hey - they both read just as much as I did - so I'll settle for that!

You might also like

Book Review: By Its Cover, a Commissario Guido Brunetti Myster...

By Its Cover, the twenty-third Commissario Guido Brunetti mystery by Donna Le...

Live Wire by Harlan Coben

A Book Review of Best Selling Author's Latest Novel

The Jewels of Paradise by Donna Leon, on Baroque Musician Agos...

The Jewels of Paradise by Donna Leon acquaints readers with Baroque musician ...

Disclosure: This page generates income for authors based on affiliate relationships with our partners, including Amazon, Google and others.
Loading ...