Discriminating Prejudice Against Pretty People
I had to smile to find this here today, as I've just been reading about the same debates, but over 150 years ago.
I've just finished re-reading Jane Eyre (and got a lot more out of it than I did when I was 15!). One of the most radical things about the eponymous heroine is that she's plain, bordering on ugly. Charlotte Bronte tells us this about a million times in the narrative.
Other people's reactions to her, within the story, often start with how plain she is. In contrast, characters like Blanche Ingram and Rosamond Oliver are so gorgeous, they're like angels or goddesses.
Jane certainly discriminates against them. She tells the reader endlessly about how much she admires them for their beauty, but then dismisses them in the next breath. It's like their beauty is a metaphor for being the wrong kind of person.
In the context of Victorian times, Jane Eyre was downright radical though. No heroine in a novel (or other literary genre) before her had been plain. They all had to be beautiful. Charlotte got a lot of bad reviews solely on the basis that Jane Eyre wasn't good-looking.
That we are still discussing this now (and with very good reason) shows how little human nature changes in 165 years. :)
JoHarrington, Sep 11, 2012