Movie Review of The Thing That Couldn't Die

by StevenHelmer

A review of the 1958 horror movie starring William Reynolds and Andra Martin

Synopsis: While digging a new well, a group of California ranchers discovers a buried medieval box they believe contains treasure from Sir Francis Drake. Instead, the box contains the still-living severed head of a 16th-century criminal and devil worshiper that has the ability to control people's minds and a desire to find his body.

Who's in it?

The movie stars William Reynolds, Carolyn Kearney, Andra Martin, Jeffrey Stone and Peggy Converse.

The Thing That Couldn't Die

"If ye valuest thy immortal soul, open not this accursed chest." So reads the inscription on the 400-year-old metal box found by teen psychic Jessica Burns (Carolyn Kearney) on ...

View on Amazon

Why Don't They Listen to Her?

My daughter and I picked this film to be our weekly father/daughter movie and, based on the description, I did think it was going to be halfway decent. However, the movie just wasn't quite what I was expecting it to be.

I will give William Reynolds some credit for being surprisingly creepy as the powerful severed head. He didn't say anything throughout the majority of the movie (rather than the unheard whispers he mutters when possessing people) and had to rely primarily on facial expressions. Despite the difficulty of that task, he did really well.

The fact he could control people was also a nice touch because it made it easy for the head to manipulate the situation to get what it wanted and, by possessing people that were trusted, could do some pretty serious damage.

However, the movie does tend to drag on a bit in between the very few intense scenes and, because of that, wasn't as enjoyable as we thought it would be. The editors could have cut quite a bit out of this film and it would have been considerably better had there not been so much inaction.

Another thing that I was personally bothered by was the way Kearney's character, Jessica, was pretty much ignored throughout the film. She proved, very early on in the movie, she had considerably psychic powers and, both after finding a missing watch and apparently causing a tree branch to fall, you would think her family would pay attention when she cautioned them about digging in a specific "evil" spot and bringing the mysterious box inside the house. Instead, they simply refused to listen to her and were put in danger as a result. How stupid were these people?

The Classic Sci-Fi Ultimate Collection: Volume 2

Get ready for the adventure of a lifetime when The Classic Sci-Fi Ultimate Collection returns with 5 captivating science fiction films from the golden age of Hollywood! Featurin...

View on Amazon

Final Opinion

This movie sounds much more interesting than it really is, in part because there's really not a lot of action or suspense. As a result, it wasn't as enjoyable as I hoped it would be.

My Grade: C

Timeless Horror - Movies 4 You

The Face of Marble (1946) Engrossed in his mission to bring the dead back to life, Dr. Randolph fails to notice his wife Elaine's interest in his young lab associate, Dr. Cochra...

View on Amazon

Updated: 12/14/2014, StevenHelmer
Thank you! Would you like to post a comment now?



You might also like

Movie Review: King Solomon's Mines

A review of the 1950 epic starring Stewart Granger as the legendary hunter Al...

Movie Review of Dr. Jekyll and Mr. Hyde

A review of the 1941 movie starring Spencer Tracy and Ingrid Bergman.

Movie Review: The Return of the Vampire (1943)

A review of the 1943 horror movie starring Bela Lugosi as the vampire Armand ...

Disclosure: This page generates income for authors based on affiliate relationships with our partners, including Amazon, Google and others.
Loading ...