The Whitechapel series isn't merely an excuse to use copy-cat crime ad nauseam. That's fun, but it would quickly lose its realism, if that was the case. Not to mention the fact that it would be very bad luck for the borough involved!
When the second series was announced, I think most people groaned a little. The first had been so good, that repeating it could only dilute the concept. No area would attract so many psychotic historians. The fact that they had one was incredible enough.
Ben Court and Christine Ip didn't do that to their viewers. Every story has a different twist and another way to utilize the lessons of the past, in the investigations of the present.
Jack the Ripper wasn't Whitechapel's only world-famous criminal. During the swinging Sixties, the Kray Twins reigned supreme from neighboring Bethnal Green. But their street ran straight through the border and some of their crimes were committed in those pubs.
Styled after the Mafia, Ronnie and Reggie Kray were eventually caught and locked away. They both died behind bars, after each spending over thirty years there. Hence it's a little perturbing for Chandler et al to discover that another set of Kray twins are terrifying local residents into silence.
There are no hidden dimensions here. Jimmy and Johnny are quite open about their gangster activities, safe in the knowledge that nothing will stick long enough to warrant their arrest. But Buchan has access to the original Kray police files. Will he find mistakes in history, that can be prised open now?
Comments
When you've got the whole range of human history coupled with a show aiming for realism, then it's inevitable that there's going to be some cross-over. With Whitechapel, that's intended. :D
I've never seen Criminal Minds. I'll have to check if we have it in Britain.
I've never even heard of the series, but you brought up an interesting point about fictional shows sometimes being far more based in reality than most realize. I don't know if you've ever heard of it, but I really love the show Criminal Minds. It is true that a lot of times when the show really manages to creep me out, I find solace in the thought that I don't see the events of the show *really* happening in everyday life. Then I saw an episode that was really disturbing, but something rang true about it, and I later realized that almost the exact same thing that happened in the episode really did happen to a little girl about ten years ago, I just happened to catch a documentary-like program about what had happened to her back then. And now the show has a bit of an edge for me, because as these fictional FBI criminal psychologist sit there discussing the inner-working of the minds of some of the most disturbing psychopaths imaginable, I sit there wondering...just how close to reality are we right now in this episode?
My Mum watches Doc Martin and really enjoys it. I've been to St Ives, where it's set, and it's beautiful down there.
I love British TV and movies. I wish we could get them here in the U.S. I discovered Doc Martin on Netflix. Now I'm sad that I can't get the new shows until they're old shows.
Ooops! Well spotted and I'll correct that now.
I love it. I don't want much television, because I'm partially deaf, so the audio is too much hassle. But this is one that I'll make an exception for. It entertains me, while also pinging against my interests as an historian.
This is really interesting. I don't watch BBC often but this sounds like something I'll look into.
It's poring over, not pouring over, by the way. :)