Movie Review: Sherlock Holmes Faces Death (1943)

The movie stars Basil Rathbone, Nigel Bruce, Dennis Hoey, Hillary Brooke and Arthur Margetson.

I originally started watching this movie earlier this week, when I was attempting to use our treadmill while home at lunch. My workout didn't turn out to be as productive as I intended (my cat kept interfering). But, I saw enough of the movie to catch my interest and eventually sat down to watch it later.

I've seen several Rathbone/Bruce Sherlock Holmes movies and have had a wide range of mixed opinions about them. This one, however, proved to be one of my favorites.

I think the thing I really liked best about this film was it had a very solid mystery. The film quickly rules out the two most obvious killers (one is killed and the other is in prison at the time of the second murder). And, once that happens, there's no clear suspect.

The only potential exception to this would be their sister, Sally (Brooke), because she is also an heir. But, since the inheritance comes with no money, that motive is a pretty weak one. Plus, the killer framed her fiance.

The house also is full of plenty of other potential suspects, including a suspicious-acting butler (Halliwell Hobbes) and soldiers who could be mentally unstable enough to do it. But, again, none of the house guest have any apparent motive (financial or otherwise) and it still doesn't explain why the doctor (Margetson) was also attacked.

When the movie first introduced the very puzzling "Musgrave Ritual" poem, I wasn't really sure what to think. I thought, correctly, it would prove to be a clue. However, at least at first, it just seemed to be gibberish, making the long-time family tradition of having the next in line memorize and recite it seem almost pointless. And, I must admit, I was pleasantly surprised when Holmes figured it out.

Probably my only real complaint about this movie is, while it does a good job with the overall mystery, it kind  of ruins that effort later on by inexplicably having the killer give himself away through his actions. As a result, when Holmes sets his final trap, there's really not as much of a surprise as there probably could have been (even though the killer's motive, admittedly, were still a little vague). Fortunately, the rest of the movie does make up for that.

As I said before, this is one of the better Rathbone/Bruce Sherlock Holmes films. There's a good mystery with plenty of suspects and, because the motive behind the murders remains unclear until the very end, it's entertaining even when the killer reveals himself. I do recommend the movie as a result of that.

My Grade: A