Cardiff Giant American Hoax

by wcascade40

A petrified giant was discovered to great excitement in rural New York, but all was not as it seemed.

Upstate New York in the 1860’s was the site of possibly the greatest hoax in American history. Certainly it was very financially success for the perpetrators and others. In 1868, George Hull, tobacconist, of Binghamton, New York was annoyed with his local preacher, Reverend Tuck. The reverend was found of giving fire and brimstone sermons. He would quote Genesis “There were giants on the earth in those days.” So George Hull decided to take the preacher at his word.

He lived in the New York state town of Binghamton, but he didn’t think his town needed a giant, but Cardiff, New York did. Hull bought a 5 ton block of gypsum stone in Iowa and had it shipped to a stonecutter in Chicago.

The stone was shaped into a rough figure of a giant man. Then the maker, Edward Salle, used darning needles to punch holes into the stone, to resemble pores. The figure was also rubbed with sand and sprayed with ink and sulfuric acid. It cost Hull about 2,600 dollars to have the stone made and buried.

giant in ground
giant in ground
statue on view
statue on view

Hull then has his huge stone man transported to his cousin William Newell’s farm near Cardiff. Then Hull waited for over a year before actually setting his hoax in motion. On October 16, 1869, Newell sent some workers to dig a well behind his barn, right where the 10 foot giant had been buried. The workers soon stumbled upon the giant and told the “surprised” farmer all about it.


Thousands of people began flocking to the Newell’s farm to see the petrified man. It was the subject of general amazement, some thinking it was a petrified man and some sure it was an ancient statue.  Newell had the dirt dug out from around the figure and erected a tent over the stone man. Newell then started charging 5 cents per person and thousands paid the fee. Even when the admission fee kept going up, the crowds kept coming.


The statue was soon bought by a group of businessmen for 37,500 dollars and moved to Syracuse so more people could see and wonder at the giant.  PT Barnum soon realized what a great money-maker the Cardiff Giant was and tried to buy it for 60,000 dollars. But the businessmen refused the offer, which turned out to be a mistake. Barnum was no fool, he knew the giant was just a fake, so he had no compunction about having a replica made, which he put on exhibit in New York City. The fake soon became more popular than the actual stone man. The businessmen sued Barnum, but the judge said he would dismiss the case unless the Cardiff giant’s owners could prove their stone man wasn’t a fake. They couldn’t, so they dropped the charges.


Scientists had quickly grown skeptical about the giant. Some pointing out that there were still chisel marks on it. It was declared to be a clumsy fake, but a couple of scientists briefly believed it was a genuine fossil. Most visitors didn’t care, they just wanted to see the giant.


Journalists had also started to investigate the giant and discovered Hull’s involvement. They also found the stonecutter and that Newell had taken delivery of a large box about a year before the giant surfaced. At this point, Hell confessed , saying his aim was the embarrass the clergy. Maybe, but he and Newell made a profit of somewhere between $30,000 and $100,000 for their hoax. This is rather less than Barnum made for his fake, his profit was at least $150,000. There were no criminal consequences. People didn’t even seem to mind being hoaxed. They just gave the Cardiff Giant a new nickname “Old Hoaxey.”

current exhibit
current exhibit

The original fake stone man can still be seen at the Farmer’s Museum in Cooperstown, New York. Barnum’s fake was exhibited at his museum for years, but the plaster man is now lost in time.

Updated: 08/07/2011, wcascade40
Thank you! Would you like to post a comment now?


Only logged-in users are allowed to comment. Login
JoHarrington on 03/27/2012

i spotted Cardiff! I know Cardiff, in Wales, very well, but didn't know you had one in New York too. This is an interesting story. Thanks for telling it. :D

Karen Kay on 08/08/2011

Funny how an attempt to play a joke turned out to be a huge moneymaker. Maybe it was the massive action the brothers took.... they really worked hard on it! Great story! Thanks1

You might also like

The Women Who Fought in the American Civil War

When we imagine the heat and blood of Gettysburg, it's the men that we see st...

The Carolina Conjoined Slave Twins Born in 1851

In 1851 children who were born ill or with special needs seldom survived. Con...

Disclosure: This page generates income for authors based on affiliate relationships with our partners, including Amazon, Google and others.
Loading ...