The first book in the trilogy was published the year after Recession hit the global economy. The film was released a year after the Occupy Movement had pushed social inequality into world headlines.
The Hunger Games is patently a more extreme reading of real life, but there are some cross-over themes. It's merely the scale (or is that the honesty) which has shifted. That mirroring of reality will certainly strike a chord in audiences, which might account for its huge popularity.
I was about to write that it's only a matter of time before we see Occupy the Hunger Games as an internet slogan. But I'm too late. The Facebook page already exists; and the news headlines are full of criticism for Gossip Girl actor Penn Badgley for making similar observations.
He's quoted widely as saying, "It's the one percent [killing the kids]. I think you'd have to be blind to not see that. I was shocked to see all that in there." Before advocating revolution for both the main characters and, by implication, real society.
I have no idea who this man is. The comments imply that it's not 'cool' to listen to a word he says. He's called it spot on, from my own personal observations.
This isn't to say that Suzanne Collins, nor the movie's directors, set out to immortalize the Occupy Movement in celluloid. They are two parallel reactions to the same social backdrop. There are no protest camps in The Hunger Games; though the undertones of revolution are there, boiling beneath the surface.
The same real world undoubtedly inspired both cultural expressions though. While Occupy shine a light on the reality of the wealthiest 1% controlling and exploiting the masses; Collins wrote a story which depicts just that. And both became extremely popular, because the reading/watching/disenfranchised public patently identify with their central message.
Or, as the Libertines put it in Time for Heroes, 'We will die in the class that we were born, but that's a class of our own, my love.'
Comments
Hi Jo,
I hadn't realised that you had written this review. (I should search better) I wrote this article (which is really about the HG phenomenon) http://wizzley.com/the-hungergames-ph...
Can I ask you about the Bechdel test? In my analysis of the movie, I talk about the Socratic conversation. Katniss has an argument with herself all of the way through the books (and in the movie but we just can't hear the internal conversation as well) The conversation is about what Katniss can do in her quest for survival and still remain true to herself (Able to live with herself - don't forget there is always a little pill they can chew off their shoulder if they want to die)
I am thinking that at the time of writing you had not read the third book Mockingjay. (2 sections) It isn't a happily ever after series and Katniss struggles with what she can live with up until the end. (How will I explain what I have done to my children?) Throughout the three books (and movies) Katniss has the most important conversation a human being can possibly have - a moral argument with herself. Through this argument she grows and matures. I won't spoil the book for your readers - accept to say that by the end she has to make one heck of a big decision. (She becomes fully mature, the 1% would be proud) So I think on the Bechel test she should score extremely high............
The conversation is between two women. Two potential Katnisses. The book series is clever because we find out which woman won the internal dialogue by the choice of husband she makes at the end of the book.
* Katniss 1 would have married Gale
* Katniss 2 would have married Peeta
It is through the work of Hannah Arendt that I have muddled my way through these ideas about moral character development.
Donald Southerland (Snow) talks about the 1% and he had them in mind when acting. So the blatant connection to the Occupy movement was there at least in his mind during the making of the film. I have worked with refugees and in prisons and I don't think Katniss was far fetched as a character. People can do extraordinary things when pushed into extreme conditions.
I think the value of the books, which I am taking to be serious literature is that they show young people how to work through moral dilemma.
I am going to read this book The Haunted Land: Facing Europe's Ghosts After Communism (Tina Rosenberg) on the plane to Spain to see if I get a better understanding of it all.
I thought so too!
Thank you for your comment. By all accounts, the book is a lot more grisly, and 7 seconds of the film had to be cut for the board to award that 12a rating.
I watched the hunger games last week, I was pleasantly surprised and a bit disturbed by the subject. A very good film but I think the 12A rating should have been higher.
I'm glad that i checked it out. I don't think it's a film that will change your life, but it certainly makes an impression.
I haven't seen or read Hunger Games but I'll admit, the hype has me curious. Great article and review here!
I haven't read 'The Long Walk', though I know that it was in the same series as 'The Running Man'. You're the second person I've heard comparing it with 'The Hunger Games' though.
One of the big things about this book/film is that people come away wondering what they would have done in Katniss's situation. I can see that there would be a lot of scope for RP in it, not to mention fan fiction.
Good luck with your review! It would be very interesting to read, as you are going into it with knowledge of the books behind you.
Yes, I will be going to see it. My experience may alter though, as I intend to read the entire trilogy asap. No doubt they will have been long assimilated in my mind before 'Catching Fire' is even filmed!
I didn't see the parallel with The Running Man, but I *did* see it with The Long Walk. In fact, I made a character on The Hunger Games RPG that had an attitude similar to several of the boys in The Long Walk; he wanted to volunteer for the games because it made his death inevitable, and he wanted to sacrifice himself for the Capitol more than he wanted to bring honor to his district by winning. I loved that character, but I don't have time to RP any more and the last character I had in the games died during the Bloodbath lol
I watched the movie again tonight. Planning on writing my own review of it, but I'm not sure which platform I'm going to use yet. Most of my pages are on Squidoo and do very well there, so that's probably where I'm going to stick it. I tried a review on Hubpages and it was a total flop. I have ten or eleven lenses, but I so want to do more branching out, and the book blog's not the right place to put this one. Decisions, decisions.
I guess the big question is: Are you going to see Catching Fire?
They were nice nachos as well! Well, as nice as you can get in a cinema.
The parallels between this and 'The Running Man' are inevitable. That was my first response too, when my nephew was telling me what 'The Hunger Games' was about. Once I was watching it though, the similarities didn't extend much past the general theme.
Love the bit where you " even forgot to eat my nachos." it sounds a bit like 'Running Man' but with kids instead of adults competing to stay alive.