Movies: Slumdog Millionare and Born Into Brothels: Calcutta’s Red Light Kids

by MarenEliz

Review of these two movies centering on poverty and children in India.

India

What is it all about

Let’s explore the common features.  Both give the viewer unvarnished pictures of Indian poverty.  Furthermore, both focus on children and their remarkable resiliency for the majority of the story.   In addition, both films were made by British filmmakers in India, although Slumdog is more of a cooperative effort between the Brits and Indians.  Slightly depressing and deeply inspiring, these are films worth seeing, if you have not yet viewed them.

Slumdog Millionaire

Best Picture

 

Slumdog was completed in 2008.  Its story occurs in the city of Mumbai (Bombay.)    Although it is not officially a Bollywood film, it contains many of the Bollywood elements such as melodrama, star-crossed lovers, and much good, pop music.  Slumdog is listed as R-rated comedy-drama, which is a good way to describe it, though I think that it comes close to fantasy, as well.  Many plot developments are left unexplained or poorly developed, asking the viewer to willingly abandon expectations of credulity.  Several newspaper reviews call Slumdog a feel-good movie and obviously the Academy thought so as well, but I will offer a caution..  The many instances of graphic ( sometimes gratuitous) violence in Slumdog surprised me and most definitely did not make me feel good.   Although there is a happy-ish ending, the movie does contain a lot of downer scenes at the beginning.

Slumdog Millionaire

Only $3.99
Slumdog Millionaire

Slumdog millionaire is the story of jamal malik; an 18 year-old orphan from the slums of mumbai; who is about to experience the biggest day of his life. With the whole nation wa...

$5.00  $0.25
Slumdog Millionaire Blu-ray

$14.99  $8.05
Slumdog Millionaire

DVD

$12.03  $1.97

Born Into Brothels: Calcutta’s Red Light Kids

Best Documentary

 

In contrast,  Born Into Brothels is a 2004 documentary, transpiring in Kolkata (Calcutta.)  It shows what transpired when two foreigner photo-journalists receive grant money to give cameras and photography lessons to about twelve children whose mothers worked in the oldest profession in the world.  The story continues with production of a fundraising calendar of the children’s shots.  However, not even this sort of divine intervention can change all the fates of the young photographers.  This movie excels and understandably won an Oscar in 2005 for Best Documentary.  Because it is a documentary,  its happy or less-than-happy endings for various characters are totally true.

Born into Brothels

A tribute to the resiliency of childhood and the restorative power of art, BORN INTO BROTHELS is a portrait of several unforgettable children who live in Calcutta's red light di...

Only $9.98
Born Into Brothels: Calcutte's Red

Only $24.99
Born into Brothels by Image/Thinkfilms

Only $106.98
Born Into Brothels [DVD] [2005] [Region 1] [US Import] [NTSC]

Brand New

Both Movies

 These are both worthwhile films in their own right.  Additionally, I am glad both films contribute to American knowledge and respect and probably appreciation of things Indian.  Sometimes, persons in the U.S. focus on perceived negatives of the brother and sister humans who do not speak English or worship in Judeo-Christian establishments.  Both of these movies draw the viewer empathetically into the very difficult and courageous lives of the characters.  The films succeed in changing Indian people from “them” into “us.”  For that and all the quality features they possess, I commend them.

 

Updated: 12/20/2011, MarenEliz
 
Thank you! Would you like to post a comment now?
0

Comments


   Login

You might also like

Film Review of A Kiss for Corliss: Shirley Temple Reprises a C...

Diaries and divorce impact characters played by David Niven and Shirley Templ...

WarHorse Review

My personal review of the film War Horse, directed by Steven Spielberg.


Disclosure: This page generates income for authors based on affiliate relationships with our partners, including Amazon, Google and others.
Loading ...
Error!