As interesting and modern as these self-cleaning litter boxes are, there is still value in the old way of kitty toileting methods. The comparisons are very interesting. It also makes me wonder what cat owners used for litter boxes back in the 1700's and 1800's.
Old School Litter Boxes
The Good- Affordable, inexpensive, and can even be made using an empty cardboard box lined with plastic.
Kitty litter sprinkled with a little baking soda can absorb odors without spending more on the fancy stuff. They are cost-effective enough to put several throughout the house.
The Bad-Keeping the litter box fresh is a challenge. There will be lots of bending, stooping, lifting, and holding your nose shut with a clip to prevent fainting. If kitty has healthy kidney function and drinks plenty of water, it might feel as heavy as a box of rocks.
Self-Cleaning Litter Boxes
The Good- Cat parents get a longer break in between litter changes. They ease some of the daily hassle of doing poo checks. What they offer is an extension of time. For busy people, that alone makes them a blessing.
The Bad-Compared to the old-school pan, they can cost 10-15 times as much. Switching an old-school cat from an old-school pan to an automated contraption might be challenging.
To Answer The Question- Do They Really Work ?
Yes, they do work. However, they only do so much. They are automated up to a point. You still have to bend down, get the litter tray, wrap it up, take it to the trash, and replace the tray with a fresh one. Your cat will love watching you do all the work. After all, they are royalty.
Image Credits-Cat litter in box by CambridgeBayWeather, (CC BY-SA 3.0)
How do you solve your litter box challenges?
The automatic litter box looks good but how easy it is to cat train it. Does cat take time to adapt? Do cats like it as well? Overall, if the cats are happy using it, the owners too should be.
The cat-toileting products out there are fascinating. Soon somebody will invent disposable cat diapers for road trips.
LPerry, Just so you know, disposability isn't a turn-off in regard to the nice selections -- of which I'm tending toward the unhooded self-cleaner -- you list above. My rural neighborhood permits contained fires, reported of course at the time to dispatch so that the Fire Department doesn't get called, so disposability doesn't get in the way as long as it can be burned.
Thank you for the reference to the reviewer about the homemade permanent litter pan. I'm re-reading everybody on the English Wizzley and German PageWizz sites so I'll be able to make the adjustment once I find out what her husband did.
That is a very good point. In one of the reviews ( I cant remember which one) someone mentioned that her husband made a permanent litter pan to fit inside. They also used their own choice of litter.
LPerry, Thank you for the practical information, pretty pictures and product lines.
The unhooded self-cleaning litter box appears the most convenient in terms of if it needs to be moved -- like during area or overall housecleaning. It bothers me somewhat that they're disposable, not recyclable. But then my neighborhood permits burning so I'd rather reduce something to ashes than add to landfills.