Essentially, yes. Every movie, novel, play or short story that has ever existed, or will ever exist, will fit into one of the seven basic story plots. In fact, some would say the number of plots is even smaller, a 'quest' and 'voyage and return', for instance, are so similar that perhaps they could be morphed into one.
In any case, the problem is, as with any categorization, no matter how many pigeon holes you have, there are some stories that refuse to fit neatly into just one.
For example, I was considering adding Bedknobs and Broomsticks to the 'overcoming the monster' story type, because Miss. Price, Mr. Brown and the kids successfully ward off the invading Nazi's. However, they also go on a 'quest' to find the Star of Astoroth. And, of course, Eglantine Price undergoes something of a 'rebirth' in as far as her staunch desire to live a solitary life is concerned.
So, categorizing plots into seven basic archetypes isn't always simple. But then, placing any kind of fiction in one category has never been easy. Many of Shakespeare's plays, for instance, don't quite belong in their three genres: tragedy, comedy and history.
Nevertheless, all of your favorite stories come from the same seven basic plots. So, at least as far as writing fiction goes, there really is nothing new under the sun.
What's Your Favorite Book, Play or Film and Which of The Seven Stories Does it Conform to?
CiceroJun 21, 2016
Then the final episode results in a massive breakthrough that restores hope, and brings everything back to a happy ending. Essentially transforming all the previous stories into a rebirth story.
WiseFoolOct 13, 2015
AllysonOct 13, 2015
WiseFoolDec 19, 2013
RoseDec 18, 2013
cmoneyspinnerSep 28, 2013
WiseFoolMar 8, 2013
BrendaReevesMar 8, 2013
WiseFoolFeb 25, 2013
EliasZanettiFeb 25, 2013
Great post!!
WiseFoolFeb 24, 2013
I think, in the same way writers can use (or ignore) the three or five act structures, the seven basic plots can be useful in understanding the shape of stories that we tend to tell and what makes them 'work' or not. Whether authors or playwrights want to follow them or not is another matter entirely.
MiraFeb 24, 2013
Thank you for your response. I agree, rebirth fits the bill. But then again, if the concept is too elastic, it's not very useful. There is always an element of change regarding the characters in a story. All of that could be considered rebirth, and sometimes that would be a stretch.
Still, those 7 plots are a great idea, I think.
WiseFoolFeb 24, 2013
GuestFeb 24, 2013
WiseFoolFeb 24, 2013
P.S. I misspelled rhinoceros and the spell checker's suggestion was 'raunchiness' (I swear, it wasn't that badly misspelled). For what it's worth, I don't know Ionesco's raunchiness that well, either!
Hi Catana. Obsessive, for sure; that cannot be disputed. Entirely respect your opinion, but I do think there is some undeniable truth in the theory, even if it's just in reference to 'familiar stories', as you mentioned earlier. Really enjoyed debating this, it's been interesting.
MiraFeb 24, 2013
WiseFoolFeb 24, 2013
As for heroes and tragic figures, you're quite right, but I don't think a protagonist who isn't a hero (tragic or otherwise) means the story doesn't fit into any of the above. Scrooge isn't a 'hero', for example. Most main characters, even if they're ambiguous, are likable in some way and could, therefore, still be referred to as the hero of the piece.
Now, ambiguous endings you've got me wondering about...I'm thinking along the lines of Beckett's 'Waiting for Godot', but I think Booker would put that under comedy - it's not a 'happy ending' in the comedic tradition, but there's the confusion and misunderstanding; those things are just never resolved. I'm not sure I'd be able to find a home (in the seven) for Sartre's 'No Exit'...but I feel sure Booker would, maybe it's tragedy.
WiseFoolFeb 24, 2013
Hi, Catana. Well, I certainly think you've got a point about the 'familiar' being popular; that love for, or comfort in, what we know is definitely part of the human condition. And, of course, we're obsessed with trying to put things into neat little boxes. I don't agree that most writers lack imagination or simply pander to the masses, though. I'm not sure I totally subscribe to Booker's categorizations, but I do think there are only so many stories to tell. Are you thinking of a specific story that you feel doesn't fit into the 'seven basic plots'?