Pie Recipe With Peaches and Cream

by kimbesa

My homemade peach pie recipe is a family favorite dessert. Especially good with fresh peaches. An easy, single crust pie to make often.

My favorite peach pie recipe makes summertime a great time for pie! Come to think of it, anytime you’re looking for a fruit-filled, luscious dessert, pie can fill the bill. People who like pie are often passionate about good homemade pie, with a flavorful filling and tender crust.

This creamy homemade peach pie will do for a memorable dessert.

Homemade peach pie
Photo: kimbesa

Pie Recipe

Especially good with fresh peaches

Peaches and Cream Pie

Unbaked pie shell for a 9-inch pie
2/3 cup white sugar
4 tablespoons all purpose flour
¼ teaspoon salt
1 cup whipping cream (but not whipped)
3 to 4 large fresh peaches, or 7 or 8 canned peach halves

Prepare the pie shell according to your recipe or package directions.(Good news: you don't blind bake this crust. Go right ahead with the filling. They bake at the same time.)

Preheat oven to 400 degrees.

Make the cream component by mixing together the unwhipped cream, sugar, salt and flour. Set aside.

Peel and slice fresh peaches into the pie shell. Pour the cream mixture over them and lightly shake the pie to evenly distribute. Bake at 400 for about 35 minutes, then turn down to 350 degrees for an additional 10 minutes.

Let the pie cool completely before slicing. Keep leftovers (if you have any) in the refrigerator.

Easy and Awesome

Fresh fruit makes it special - a cool summer treat

The recipe below for Peaches and Cream Pie is based on an old family favorite, and it is outstanding with fully-ripe fruit. This recipe will also help satisfy both the pie eaters who like fruit pie, and those who like cream pies.

Early peaches come into groceries and markets starting in May, and will continue through the summer peach season, that generally ends by October. Look for fruit that is firm but smells of peaches, and is free of brown spots and mold.

Also, this pie is easiest with freestone peach varieties, where the center pit comes cleanly away from the pulp. You can use cling peaches, but you’ll have to cut the fruit away from the pit.  Redhaven, Fairhaven and Elberta are just some of the varieties you'll find on the market.

Serve pie on large dessert plates, for a generous slice and to allow for a scoop of ice cream on the side.

Peaches and Cream Pie

Peach cream pie
Photo by kimbesa

More Tips for Peaches and Cream Pie

This pie recipe is flexible
  • If you use frozen peaches, thaw and drain thoroughly before use
  • If you like blueberries, try adding a few to this pie
  • If you enjoy this pie, make two! This pie works well as a cool breakfast on a hot summer day, as well as for dessert

As for the crust, I’ve had good results with packaged, refrigerated pie crusts. When I get more practice with a scratch crust, I’ll use that more often. Good pie crust is an art.

How to Choose Fresh Peaches

Bake Pie in One of These

Pyrex Easy Grab 9.5" Glass Pie Plate
World Kitchen (PA)
$17.98  $5.11
Pyrex Easy Grab 9.5" Glass Pie Plate,...
World Kitchen (PA)
$14.99  $14.00
Emile Henry Made In France HR Modern ...
Emile Henry
$45.00  $28.45

Vintage Syracuse China Pie Plates

Once you serve pie on these larger plates, you'll want to use them all the time, especially for pie and ice cream.
Lancaster pattern by Syracuse
Lancaster pattern by Syracuse
Photo by kimbesa

Vintage Pie Plates on eBay

Collectable and charming to use, too.

Vintage Strawberry Pie Recipe Plate Pan Ceramic USA Jeannette ...

Time left: 1 week, 4 days
Current bid: $7.99  Place bid

Vintage Royal China CheeseCake Pie plate 1983 ** 2 Recipes**

Time left: 11 hours, 7 minutes
Current bid: $5.00  Place bid

Vintage 1983 Royal China Country Harvest Ceramic Pumpkin Pie R...

Time left: 3 weeks
Current bid: $12.99  Place bid

Vintage Jeannette Royal China Cheese Cake Pie Recipe Pie Plate...

Time left: 1 day, 3 hours
Current bid: $7.99  Place bid
More of My Wizzley Articles
China, glassware, table linens and other accessories can be used to add fashionable pink to your table settings. Entertain with pink for girl birthdays, ladies tea parties.
Mom's favorite dishes -- dinnerware and foods -- can inspire gift and tableware ideas for Mother's Day, birthdays, or other special dinners to honor your Mom.
Dishes in Corelle are durable, stylish, and work well for casual parties and everyday meals.
Updated: 08/16/2015, kimbesa
Thank you! Would you like to post a comment now?

Is Peaches and Cream Pie For You?

kimbesa on 05/26/2013

I didn't give a crust recipe. You just need a single crust, unbaked. That pre-made crust that comes rolled up in a box is fine, for convenience. One day I'll be as good a pie crust as I am at pizza crust. Have to develop a different touch for pie!

Mira on 05/26/2013

Oh, I love peaches in desserts. I'll try your pie :):) Do you put flour in the cream mix as well? If so, how much? And how come you use only 4 tablespoons for the crust? Wait, I see I had asked you about this in September! So 4 tbsp in the cream mix. How much in the crust?

kimbesa on 05/21/2013

Once you make this, you'll look forward to fresh peaches every year!

katiem2 on 05/21/2013

Pie is my all time favorite food bar none. I have friends who have several peace trees so I'm looking forward to making and eating this tasty pie. thanks

kimbesa on 05/10/2013

Four tablespoons.

Mira on 09/02/2012

So how much flour do I put in the cream mix?

barbarab on 09/06/2011

who doesnt love pie

poutine on 07/09/2011

Mouth watering recipe to use all those peaches.


kimbesa on 06/21/2011

Organic peaches sound even more fantastic! I didn't think this pie could get any better but I'll bet that would be great. Thanks!

ohcaroline on 06/21/2011

This sounds like a great peach pie recipe. I'd like to try it. I have an organic orchard nearby that you can pick yourself. Great article.

You might also like

Mom's Peach Pie Recipe for Thanksgiving

Mom baked her peach pies with fresh peaches and a special Thanksgiving life l...

Peach Cobbler Recipe With Agave Nectar

This easy peach cobbler recipe uses agave nectar, which really brings out the...

Disclosure: This page generates income for authors based on affiliate relationships with our partners, including Amazon, Google and others.
Loading ...